SEO Bedford · The study

What Bedford's Top-Ranking Businesses Do on Google: 17 Industries Audited

Every day, people in Bedford search Google for a plumber, a dentist or somewhere to eat, yet only a handful of businesses ever get picked. We looked at who those businesses are across 17 industries and what they have in common will surprise you, especially as most of it costs nothing to copy.

Updated: November 2026
Written by: Andrew Odgers, Director
Written for: Bedford business owners
Reading time: 18 minutes

Introduction

When someone in Bedford needs a local business, they nearly always choose from the first few names that Google shows them, which is why appearing in those places is essential for any Bedford business that wants to drive more revenue. This study looks at who holds those places today and why they are there.

Google shows local businesses in two places: a box near the top containing a map and three businesses, known as the map pack, followed by a list of websites underneath it, known as the organic results. We studied both across 17 Bedford searches.

The map pack is won on Google rather than on your website. The businesses in the top three keep their Google listing complete, have recent reviews and reply to them, whereas their websites are no better than those of the businesses directly below them.

The list of websites is dominated by directories and large chains. Sites such as Checkatrade, Tripadvisor and Rightmove, along with national chains, take most of the places, although small local websites still manage to rank, often with very little behind them.

Very few businesses write about Bedford like a local. We found that very few local business websites mention a single Bedford street, village or landmark, which makes local detail the easiest way for a business to stand out.

Three numbers from the study

The study in numbers

  • 17Bedford searches
  • 51businesses in the map pack
  • 119businesses just below them
  • 85web pages in the first five
  • 150local websites read

What You See When You Search Google

When you type something such as plumbers bedford into Google, the results page that comes back can contain up to three parts.

  1. Sponsored results. These are adverts that businesses pay for, which Google labels as Sponsored. We left them out of this study.
  2. The map pack. This is a map with three local businesses listed underneath it, each showing a star rating. The listings come from Google Business Profiles, which are the free listings that businesses set up on Google. A map pack appeared in all 17 of our searches.
  3. The organic results. This is the ordinary list of websites, which Google chooses itself and which nobody can pay to appear in.

Key Terms Used in This Study

We have kept jargon to a minimum, although where a term couldn't be avoided, this is what it means.

Map pack
The box near the top of Google's results that shows a map with three local businesses.
Google Business Profile
The free listing that puts a business on Google Maps, holding its address, opening hours, photos and reviews.
Organic results
The ordinary list of websites below the map pack, which nobody can pay to appear in.
Directory
A website that lists lots of businesses, such as Checkatrade, Yell or Tripadvisor.
Category
The label a business chooses on its Google listing to describe what it is, such as Plumber or Florist.
Page title and main heading
The page title is usually the blue link that Google shows, whereas the main heading is the large headline at the top of the page itself.
Schema markup
Hidden code on a web page that labels details such as the business name and address for search engines.
Authority score
An outside tool's estimate of how strong a website is, which is not a Google measure.
Chain page
A page on a national chain's website about one of its local branches, such as its Bedford gym or hotel.
Page speed
How quickly a page loads, which we tested using Google's free PageSpeed Insights tool on its mobile setting.

How We Carried Out the Study

To make the study a fair test, every search was carried out in exactly the same way.

One search for each type of business. We chose 17 types of local business and, for each one, used the search that people in Bedford type most often according to our keyword data. These range from massage bedford, which is searched around 2,400 times a month, down to plasterer bedford at around 110.

The same conditions every time. Each search was carried out once on a desktop computer in Bedford while signed out of Google. The first ten were searched on 10 November 2026, with the remaining seven following on 11 November.

Who we recorded. For every search we noted the three businesses in the map pack, the next seven in Google's longer list of local businesses and the first five websites in the organic results. This gave us 51 map pack businesses, 119 businesses directly below them and 85 web pages to analyse.

What we checked on each Google listing. We recorded each listing's reviews, star rating, the date of its most recent review and how many reviews the owner had replied to. We also looked at its categories, photos, services, address, distance from St Paul's Square and whether its description and opening hours had been filled in.

What we checked on each website. For each page we noted what kind of page it was, its title and main heading, its length and whether it used schema markup. We also took an outside estimate of each website's strength and visitor numbers and tested how quickly it loaded on a mobile phone using Google's PageSpeed Insights. Finally, we read 150 local business websites to see what they actually say.

What to bear in mind. Google's results change over time and depend on where the person searching is located, so this study is a snapshot of one particular moment. In fact, between our main searches and a second search for the longer list of local businesses, Google had already reshuffled its top three for 6 of the 17 searches.

Who we name. We name the businesses that reached a top three or the first five websites, whereas we don't name the businesses below them. One business in our results is a Lillian Purge client, Towerstone Accountants, which was second in the map pack for accountants bedford.

Businesses with complete and accurate info are more likely to show up in local search results.

Google, Tips to improve your local ranking on Google

What the Map Pack Leaders Do

These are the patterns we found across the 51 businesses that reached a top three, with each one followed by a practical step you can take.

Reviews: Quality Beats Quantity

Reviews matter. In 13 of our 17 searches, the typical business in the top three had more reviews than the typical business in the seven below it, however, the business with the most reviews doesn't automatically win. We found that only 24 of the 51 leaders were among the three most reviewed businesses in their own list.

The number of reviews you need depends on your trade. A typical restaurant, hotel, pub or takeaway in the top three had around 480 reviews, whereas a typical trade or service business had around 120. Three businesses even reached a top three with fewer than 15 reviews: the gym Foundry. with 12, The Balance & Bliss (Accountants) Ltd with 13 and L&P Elite Roofing with 14.

Star ratings were high almost everywhere, with the typical leader holding 4.9 stars and none falling below 4.0. Even so, Premier Inn, Mercure and Holiday Inn Express all made the hotels top three with 4.1 stars.

The bigger difference was what owners did with their reviews. 35 of the 51 leaders had a newest review that Google dated a week ago or more recently and the typical leader had replied to 6 of its last 10 reviews, compared with just 2 for the typical business below the top three.

What the leaders do with their reviews

Typical number of reviews in a top three

  • Restaurants, hotels, pubs and takeawaysabout 480
  • Trades and other servicesabout 120
  • Smallest in any top three12

Middle values across the 51 map pack businesses.

Categories: Choosing the Right One

When you set up a Google listing you choose a main category, such as Plumber, Florist or Estate agent. Most leaders chose the obvious category for the search, although a few picked a closely related one, such as a gas engineer appearing in the plumbers top three.

Choosing the right category gets you into the list, although it won't put you at the top on its own. 95 of the 119 businesses just below the top three used one of the same categories as the leaders, while 23 of the 51 leaders hadn't added any extra categories at all.

Categories

  • Businesses just below the top three using one of the leaders' categories95 of 119
  • Leaders with no extra categories added23 of 51

Each bar shows the share of its own group.

Your Google Listing: Completing the Basics

The leaders keep their basic details complete. 88% have a description written by the business, compared with 70% of the businesses just below them, while 47 of the 51 list their opening hours and 41 link to their social media pages.

None of the 51 leaders showed a list of services on their Google listing and only 7 of the 119 businesses below them did. Because we searched while signed out of Google, some visitors may see services that we couldn't, although either way a list of services isn't what separates the leaders from the rest.

When you click the Website button, 42 of the 51 leaders send you to their homepage, whereas not one sends you to a page about the service you searched for.

How the leaders fill in their Google listing

Photos: More Isn't Always Better

The typical leader had 33 photos on its listing, whereas the typical business just below had 40, which suggests that adding more photos doesn't earn a place on its own. Tradespeople mostly showed photos of finished jobs.

Typical number of photos on a Google listing

  • Map pack leaders33
  • The seven just below40

Google only showed the date of the newest photo on 11 of the 51 listings, so we were unable to tell how recent anyone's photos were.

Your Address and the Town Centre

49 of the 51 leaders show a full street address, although being close to the middle of town isn't what got them there. The typical leader was 1.4 miles from St Paul's Square, whereas the businesses just below were closer at 1.1 miles. Restaurants, hotels, pubs and takeaways are the exception, because most of them are in the town centre anyway.

Among tradespeople, only 2 of the 18 in the top three hid their address and showed the area they cover instead, compared with 12 of the 42 below them.

Typical distance from St Paul's Square

  • Map pack top three
  • The seven just below

Middle values. Rings are drawn to scale with each other, not to a map.

How the Leaders Compare with the Businesses Below

The chart below places the leaders side by side with the businesses directly beneath them, showing that most of the gaps are in how well each business looks after its Google listing.

The top three look after their Google listings better

Share of businesses on each measure

Map pack top three (51)The seven just below (119)

  • Description written by the business
  • Replied to 8 or more of the last 10 reviews
  • Newest review dated a week ago or more recently
  • Website has a Bedford service page*
  • Bedford or the service in the business name
  • Street address shown
  • Opening hours listed
*Covers the 13 service industries, counting businesses with a website: 37 in the top three and 81 below them. Source: our audit of Google results for 17 Bedford searches, 10 to 12 November 2026.

When you reply to customer reviews, it shows that you value their feedback.

Google, Tips to improve your local ranking on Google

What Gets a Website into the First Five

The organic results are the list of websites shown underneath the map pack. We looked at the first five for each search, which gave us 85 pages in total.

Who Takes the Top Five Places

Directories and large chains take most of the places. 33 of the 85 went to directories and booking sites such as Checkatrade, Tripadvisor, Rightmove and Booking.com, while another 13 went to the Bedford pages of national chains. Local businesses' own websites took 33 and four went to Bedford pages on the websites of firms covering several towns, while the remaining two went to a Bedford Borough Council page and a local blog.

Who holds the 85 places in the first five websites

  • Directories and booking sites 33
  • National chains 13
  • Local business websites 33
  • Firms covering several towns 4
  • A council page and a local blog 2

Directories and booking sites came first in 12 of the 17 searches, with Checkatrade taking first place for plumbers, electricians, roofers and plasterers. Only four local websites came first: thetreesurgeonbedford.co.uk, Bedford Accountants, Bedford Window Cleaning and Motorvation Bedford.

Who came first in the list of websites across 17 searches

  • Directories and booking sites 12
  • National chain 1
  • Local business websites 4

We also found that only 14 of the 51 map pack leaders had their website in the first five, meaning that for most searches Google shows one set of businesses on the map and a different set in the list.

Small Websites Can Still Rank

The local websites in the first five were small. On an outside estimate of website strength, a typical one scored 10, compared with 48 for the pages of national chains and 64 for directories. The same tool estimated that these local websites receive around 300 visits a month, while five of them had web addresses that were no more than three years old.

Typical website strength on an outside tool's score

  • Directories64
  • National chain pages48
  • Local business websites that ranked10

Scored out of 100 by a third-party tool, which is not a Google measure.

Titles and Headings

Every web page has a title, which Google usually shows as the blue link, as well as a main heading, which is the large headline at the top of the page. Bedford appeared in 77 of the 85 page titles and the 8 without it all belonged to local business websites.

Main headings were less consistent, with only 13 of the 33 local websites including Bedford in theirs and 7 having no main heading at all.

Titles, headings and descriptions

Google doesn't always use the short description that a page supplies to appear under the link and in our study it wrote its own for 44 of the 85 results.

What the Ranking Pages Contain

The local pages that ranked were short, with a typical page containing around 500 words and seven containing fewer than 300.

20 of the 33 local websites showed photos of their own work and 15 listed the areas they cover, although only 7 showed prices and just 2 included questions and answers.

What the 33 local websites in the first five show

  • Photos of their own work20
  • The areas they cover15
  • Prices7
  • Questions and answers2

We also read 150 local business websites from across our searches and found that only 19 named a single Bedford street, village or landmark in their writing. None of them said who had written the page.

Schema Markup

Schema markup is hidden code that labels details such as your business name, address and opening hours for search engines. 70 of the 85 pages had some form of it, including every national chain page, whereas 10 of the 33 local websites in the first five had none, which shows that it isn't a requirement for getting there.

Schema markup

Page Speed

We tested every page with Google's PageSpeed Insights on its mobile setting and found that almost all of them were slow. Only 5 of the 85 scored 90 out of 100 or more, while 72 took more than four seconds to show their main content, which Google's own scale counts as poor. Interestingly, the local business websites were faster than both the national chain pages and the directories.

Page speed on a mobile phone

19 of 150

local business websites named a single Bedford street, village or landmark.

None of the 150 said who had written the page.

Why Google Shows These Results

Google's guide to local ranking breaks local results down into three factors: relevance, distance and prominence. Our findings line up with all three of them. Read Google's guide.

  1. Relevance

    How closely a listing matches the search. Google asks businesses to provide complete and detailed information, which fits with the leaders choosing the obvious category and 88% of them writing a description.

  2. Distance

    How far a business is from the person searching. This may explain why our measurement from St Paul's Square didn't match the rankings, as someone searching in Kempston may see a different top three to someone in the town centre.

  3. Prominence

    How well known a business is. Google says that more reviews and positive ratings can help, which fits with 35 of the 51 leaders having a newest review that Google dated a week ago or more recently.

Our view of the list of websites. Directories list hundreds of businesses and their websites are far stronger than those of local firms. For a broad search such as plumbers bedford, a page listing many plumbers is a reasonable answer, which may be why directories often come first. However, a local business can still earn a place with a clear page about exactly what it does in Bedford, as 34 of them did in our study.

“There's no way to request or pay for a better local ranking on Google.”

16 of 18

tradespeople in the map pack had fewer than 150 reviews.

In Bedford's trades, you don't need hundreds of reviews to reach the top three.

Industry by Industry

Every industry had its own pattern, although these are the ones that stood out most.

Restaurants, Pubs and Takeaways

The three map pack restaurants were all in the town centre, around a tenth of a mile from St Paul's Square. In the list of websites, Tripadvisor came first for both restaurants and pubs, while the first four places for takeaways went to Just Eat, Tripadvisor, Uber Eats and GoGetters.

Hotels

The map pack went to three chain hotels, Premier Inn, Mercure and Holiday Inn Express, each with 4.1 stars. Booking and review sites took four of the first five websites, leaving The Bedford Swan Hotel & Thermal Spa as the only hotel with its own website in the first five.

Gyms

All five websites in the first five were local pages belonging to gym chains, while the smallest review count in any top three belonged to a gym, with Foundry. holding just 12.

Trades

Checkatrade came first for plumbers, electricians, roofers and plasterers, although local businesses still held their own. Tree surgeons had four local websites in the first five, with thetreesurgeonbedford.co.uk taking first place, while 16 of the 18 tradespeople in the map pack had fewer than 150 reviews.

Professional Services

For accountants, Bedford Accountants came first in the list of websites ahead of every directory, whereas dentists saw the NHS website first and estate agents saw Rightmove first.

Bedford's Biggest Searches

According to our keyword data, massage bedford is the most searched of all 17 at around 2,400 times a month. Restaurants bedford and bedford hotels follow at around 1,900 each, with pubs in bedford and dentist bedford next at around 1,300.

The Full Table

The table shows one row for each industry in order of monthly searches, with the review figure showing the middle value for the three map pack leaders.

The 17 industries in our study, in order of monthly searches
IndustrySearchSearches a monthTypical reviews in the top threeTop three also in the first five websitesFirst website listed
Massage and spasmassage bedford2,4001212 of 3Gumtree
Restaurantsrestaurants bedford1,9004171 of 3Tripadvisor
Hotelsbedford hotels1,9009200 of 3Booking.com
Pubs and barspubs in bedford1,3001,4060 of 3Tripadvisor
Dentistsdentist bedford1,3004261 of 3NHS website
Estate agentsestate agents bedford1,0003441 of 3Rightmove
Gymsgym bedford1,0003811 of 3The Gym Group
MOT and repairsmot bedford1,0002920 of 3Motorvation Bedford
Takeawaystakeaway bedford7201300 of 3Just Eat
Car dealersused cars bedford7205321 of 3Autotrader
Plumbersplumbers bedford480561 of 3Checkatrade
Electricianselectrician bedford390421 of 3Checkatrade
Accountantsaccountants bedford320380 of 3Bedford Accountants
Tree surgeonstree surgeon bedford210801 of 3thetreesurgeonbedford.co.uk
Roofersroofers bedford1701471 of 3Checkatrade
Window cleanerswindow cleaner bedford170652 of 3Bedford Window Cleaning
Plasterersplasterer bedford110571 of 3Checkatrade

Hotels, pubs, takeaways, MOT centres and accountants had no overlap at all between the map pack and the first five websites.

No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.

Google, Do you need an SEO?

What to Do Next

The checklist below brings together everything in this study, with each point based on what the leaders we studied actually do.

  1. Choose the main category on your Google listing that matches what your customers search for.
  2. Write a description of your business and add your opening hours.
  3. If customers come to you, show your address. If you travel to them, show the area you cover instead.
  4. Ask customers for a review as a normal part of every job, so that new reviews keep arriving.
  5. Reply to your reviews regularly, especially any that are negative.
  6. Include your service and Bedford in your website's page titles and main headings.
  7. Show photos of your own work and list the areas you cover.
  8. Write about the streets, villages and places you actually work in, as almost nobody else does.

None of this can guarantee first place, as Google itself confirms, although these steps will put your business in the best possible position to be found. Read Google's guidance on hiring SEO help.

If you would like help putting this into practice, our SEO for Bedford businesses service starts with an audit of your website and your Google Maps listing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a website to appear on Google Maps?
Not necessarily, as Harrowden Road Mot & Service Centre Ltd made the MOT top three without a website at all, although the other 50 leaders all linked to one. A website also gives you a second chance to be found in the list of websites below the map.
Will having more reviews than my competitors put me first?
Not on its own, as only 24 of the 51 leaders were among the three most reviewed businesses in their list. What set the leaders apart was having recent reviews and replying to them.
Does it matter if my business isn't in the town centre?
Not a great deal in our study, as the leaders were actually slightly further from St Paul's Square than the businesses below them. Google measures distance from the person searching rather than from the town centre.
Why do sites such as Checkatrade appear above my website?
Directories list many businesses and have much stronger websites, so Google often shows them for broad searches. Checkatrade came first for plumbers, electricians, roofers and plasterers, although local websites still made the first five in every one of those searches.
Can anyone guarantee my business first place on Google?
No, Google states that nobody can guarantee a number one ranking, so be wary of anyone who promises one.

Sources

  1. Our audit of Google results for 17 Bedford searches, recorded between 10 and 12 November 2026.
  2. Google: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google
  3. Google: Guidelines for representing your business on Google
  4. Google: SEO Starter Guide
  5. Google: Do you need an SEO?
  6. Google: Understanding page experience in Google Search results
  7. Google: PageSpeed Insights

Written by Andrew Odgers

Andrew is a director of Lillian Purge, the Bedford agency behind this study. Before moving into SEO, he worked as a contract auditor in the public sector and then as a circulation auditor in the media industry.

More about Andrew and the team