SEO Bedford · Map pack and organic

Bedford Map Pack vs Organic Results: Why Google Shows Different Businesses

Search for a plumber in Bedford and Google shows you two lists, a map with three businesses and a list of websites underneath, which rarely feature the same names. We compared both lists for 17 Bedford searches to find out how often they match and who fills the gap.

Updated: November 2026
Written by: Andrew Odgers, Director
Written for: Bedford business owners
Reading time: 10 minutes

Introduction

When someone in Bedford searches for a local service, Google usually shows two separate lists on the same page. The map pack shows three local businesses on a map, while the organic results underneath list websites, which often belong to completely different businesses.

This article builds on our audit of 17 Bedford industries on Google by comparing the two lists for every search, to see how often the same businesses appear in both and who fills the organic places instead.

Most map pack businesses weren't in the organic results. Only 14 of the 51 businesses in the map pack top three also had their website in the first five websites.

The same business rarely came first in both. In only 1 of the 17 searches did the same business take first place in the map pack and in the organic results.

Directories filled the gap. Directories and booking sites took 33 of the 85 organic places and came first in 12 of the 17 searches.

Businesses just outside the map pack still reached the organic list. Businesses ranking lower down the local results took 13 organic places, including first place in four searches.

Three numbers from the study

The two lists we compared

  • 17Bedford searches
  • 51businesses in the map pack top three
  • 85places in the first five websites
  • 14businesses that appeared in both lists
  • 1 of 17searches where the same business came first in both

Two Lists on One Page

The map pack and the organic results look as though they are part of the same list, although Google builds them in different ways. The map pack is drawn from Google Business Profiles, the free listings that put businesses on Google Maps, whereas the organic results are made up of web pages from across the internet.

The map pack
  1. 1Business AIts website also appears in the organic list
  2. 2Business B
  3. 3Business C
The organic results
  1. 1A directory page listing local businesses
  2. 2A booking site or second directory
  3. 3A national chain’s Bedford page
  4. 4Business A’s website
  5. 5A business from lower down the local results
An illustration of the most common pattern in our study rather than a real search. The colours match the charts further down this page.

Because they are built differently, a business can do well in one list and be missing from the other. A plumber with a strong Google listing and many reviews might sit in the map pack while its website is nowhere near the first five, whereas a directory such as Checkatrade can lead the organic results without appearing in the map pack at all.

Key Terms Used in This Article

We have kept jargon to a minimum, although where a term couldn't be avoided, this is what it means.

Map pack
The box near the top of Google's results that shows a map with three local businesses underneath it.
Organic results
The ordinary list of websites below the map pack, which nobody can pay to appear in.
Local results
The full list of businesses on Google Maps for a search, of which the map pack shows the first three.
Google Business Profile
The free listing that puts a business on Google Maps, holding its address, opening hours, photos and reviews.
Directory
A website that lists many businesses of one type in one place, such as Checkatrade or Tripadvisor.
Booking site
A website where customers book directly, such as Booking.com for hotels or Just Eat for takeaways.

How We Compared the Two Lists

We used the same 17 Bedford searches as our wider study, each carried out once on a desktop computer in Bedford while signed out of Google, with the first ten searched on 10 November 2026 and the remaining seven on 11 November.

What we recorded. For each search we recorded the three businesses in the map pack, the businesses in places four to ten of the full local results and the first five websites in the organic results.

How we matched them. We matched each business in the local results to the organic results by its website address, so a business counted as appearing in both lists only when its own website was among the first five.

How we grouped the organic places. We sorted each of the 85 organic places into four groups, namely websites of map pack top-three businesses, websites of businesses lower in the local results, directories and booking sites and other businesses and pages. The last group includes national chains, firms covering several towns, local businesses that weren’t in the local results at all, a council page and a local blog, as described in our study of the page types that rank in Bedford.

What to bear in mind. Both lists change over time and with where the person searching is, so this is a snapshot of mid-November 2026. We name only businesses that reached the map pack top three or the first five websites.

How Often the Map Pack Top Three Also Appear in the Organic Top Five

Across the 17 searches, only 14 of the 51 businesses in the map pack top three also had their website in the first five organic results. In other words, almost three quarters of the businesses that Google placed in the map pack didn't appear in the organic list below it.

How the map pack and the first five websites overlapped in each search
IndustryMap pack top three also in the first fiveDirectories and booking sites in the first fiveBusinesses lower in the local resultsOther businesses and pages
Massage and spas2 of 3210
Restaurants1 of 3103
Hotels0 of 3410
Pubs and bars0 of 3212
Dentists1 of 3121
Estate agents1 of 3103
Gyms1 of 3031
MOT and repairs0 of 3113
Takeaways0 of 3401
Car dealers1 of 3211
Plumbers1 of 3301
Electricians1 of 3301
Accountants0 of 3212
Tree surgeons1 of 3112
Roofers1 of 3202
Window cleaners2 of 3201
Plasterers1 of 3211

We matched each business in the map pack to the organic results by its website address. The last three columns count places out of five.

Even when a map pack business did appear in the organic results, it usually sat towards the bottom of the first five. Nine of the 14 were in fourth or fifth place, while only one was in first place.

Where the 14 map pack businesses appeared in the first five websites

  • First place1 of 14
  • Second place2 of 14
  • Third place2 of 14
  • Fourth place4 of 14
  • Fifth place5 of 14

The one business to come first in both lists was Bedford Window Cleaning, which led the map pack and the organic results for window cleaner bedford. Six of the 17 map pack leaders had their website somewhere in the first five, so the business at the top of the map is not always the one at the top of the websites.

Local results are mainly based on relevance, distance and popularity.

Google, Tips to improve your local ranking on Google

Who Takes the Organic Spots Instead

If most map pack businesses aren't in the organic results, someone else is filling those places. The chart below shows who held all 85 places in the first five websites.

Who held the 85 places in the first five websites

  • Map pack top-three businesses 14
  • Businesses lower in the local results 13
  • Directories and booking sites 33
  • Other businesses and pages 25

Each square is one place in the first five websites across the 17 searches.

Directories and booking sites were the largest group by far, with 33 of the 85 places. They came first in 12 of the 17 searches, from Checkatrade for plumbers, electricians, roofers and plasterers to Tripadvisor for restaurants and pubs and Booking.com for hotels.

Businesses lower down the local results took 13 places, which shows that a business outside the map pack top three can still reach the first five websites. In four searches, the website in first place belonged to a business that sat below the top three on the map.

The remaining 25 places went to other businesses and pages, mainly national chains, firms covering several towns and local businesses that didn't appear in the local results at all, along with a council page and a local blog.

33 of 85

organic places went to directories and booking sites.

They came first in 12 of the 17 searches, whereas the map pack lists individual businesses from Google Maps.

Industries Where the Two Lists Match and Where They Split

The overlap varied a great deal by industry. Trades had the most in common between the two lists, while restaurants, hotels, pubs and takeaways had almost none.

Map pack top-three businesses that also appeared in the first five websites

  • Trades such as plumbers and roofers7 of 18
  • Other services such as dentists and gyms6 of 21
  • Restaurants, hotels, pubs and takeaways1 of 12

Each search has three map pack places, so six trade searches give 18 places.

Window cleaners and massage came closest to matching, with two of the three map pack businesses also in the first five websites. Every trade search had at least one business in both lists, which reflects how often local tradespeople's homepages ranked in the organic results.

At the other end, five searches had no overlap at all, namely hotels, pubs and bars, MOT and repairs, takeaways and accountants. In hotels and takeaways the organic results were dominated by booking and delivery sites, with four of the five places in each, while for accountants and MOTs the organic places went to a mix of directories, national chains and other local firms, with the council's own MOT page also among them.

1 of 17

searches where the same business came first in both lists.

That was Bedford Window Cleaning, first in the map pack and in the organic results for window cleaner bedford.

What It Means for Where a Business Should Focus

The checklist below turns this study into practical steps, with each one based on the two lists we compared for Bedford searches.

  1. Search for your main service in Bedford and note which businesses appear in the map pack and which websites appear below it.
  2. Treat your Google Business Profile and your website as two separate routes to customers, since only 14 of the 51 map pack businesses appeared in both.
  3. For the map pack, keep your profile complete and accurate and keep earning genuine reviews.
  4. For the organic results, give your website a clear page about your service in Bedford.
  5. Keep your listings on the main directories in your industry accurate, since directories held 33 of the 85 organic places.
  6. If you sit just outside the map pack top three, work on your website too, as businesses lower in the local results took 13 organic places.
  7. In hospitality, make the most of booking sites and review sites, which filled most of the organic places.
  8. Check both lists again every few months, as both change over time.

The map pack and the organic results reward different things, so a business that works on its Google listing and its website gives itself two chances of being found instead of one.

If you would like help appearing in both lists, our map pack and website SEO in Bedford covers your Google Business Profile and your website together.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between the map pack and the organic results?
The map pack is the box with a map and three local businesses, drawn from Google Business Profiles. The organic results are the list of websites underneath it, which Google ranks separately and which nobody can pay to appear in.
Why is my business in the map pack but not in the organic results?
The two lists are ranked differently. The map pack ranks Business Profiles on relevance, distance and how well known a business is, whereas the organic list ranks web pages. In our study 37 of the 51 businesses in the map pack top three didn't have their website in the first five.
Can a business appear in both lists?
Yes, 14 of the 51 map pack businesses in our study also had their website in the first five. Window cleaners and massage were the closest matches, with two of the three map pack businesses in both lists.
Why do directories fill so many of the organic places?
Directories build a page for each type of business in each town, which closely matches searches such as plumbers bedford. In our study they took 33 of the 85 organic places and came first in 12 of the 17 searches.
Should I focus on the map pack or the organic results?
For most local businesses the map pack is the more direct route, since it lists businesses rather than directories. However, a strong website gives you a second chance to appear, as 13 businesses that were lower in the local results reached the first five websites.

Sources

  1. Our audit of Google results for 17 Bedford searches, recorded between 10 and 12 November 2026.
  2. Google: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google

Written by Andrew Odgers

Andrew is a director of Lillian Purge, the Bedford agency behind this study. Before moving into SEO, he worked as a contract auditor in the public sector and then as a circulation auditor in the media industry.

More about Andrew and the team