SEO Bedford · Website strength

How Strong Are the Websites Behind Bedford's Top Google Results?

It is easy to assume that Google always puts the biggest websites at the top, leaving local businesses with no chance. We measured the age, links, authority and estimated traffic of every website in the first five results for 17 Bedford searches to see how often the bigger site really wins.

Updated: November 2026
Written by: Andrew Odgers, Director
Written for: Bedford business owners
Reading time: 11 minutes

Introduction

Website strength is a general term for how established a website is, judged by measures such as how long its address has existed, how many other websites link to it and how many visitors it gets. Many business owners assume that the strongest websites always take the top places on Google.

This article builds on the Bedford results we audited across 17 industries by measuring the websites behind all 85 pages in the first five, to see whether a bigger website always wins.

Directories were by far the strongest websites. On an outside tool's authority score, the typical directory scored 64 out of 100, against 48 for national chains and 10 for local business websites.

The strongest website usually came first, although not always. In 11 of the 17 searches the website in first place had the highest score of the five, while in the other six a weaker website took first place.

Four local businesses beat much stronger websites. Every local business that came first did so above a website scoring between 64 and 69, with scores of its own between 9 and 23.

Local websites were younger and smaller. The typical local website was 12 years old with 393 other websites linking to it, against 22 years and 30,400 for directories.

Three numbers from the study

The websites we measured

  • 85web pages in the first five
  • 64typical authority score of a directory
  • 10typical authority score of a local business website
  • 11 of 17first places that went to the strongest website
  • 4local businesses that beat far stronger websites to first place

What We Measured and Where It Comes From

We used the same 17 Bedford searches as our wider study, each carried out once on a desktop computer in Bedford while signed out of Google, with the first ten searched on 10 November 2026 and the remaining seven on 11 November. For each of the 85 pages in the first five websites we recorded four measures of the website behind it.

  1. Domain age

    How many years have passed since the website's address, such as example.co.uk, was first registered. We took this from public registration records.

  2. Referring domains

    How many other websites link to the website at least once. A link from another website is often called a backlink.

  3. Authority score

    A score from 0 to 100 that an SEO tool gives each website based on its links and estimated visitors. It is the tool's own estimate and not a Google measure.

  4. Estimated traffic

    The same tool's estimate of how many visits a month the website gets from Google searches in the UK. It is a model rather than a count of real visits.

Domain age comes from public registration records. The other three measures come from a widely used SEO tool, which estimates them for the whole website using its own data, so they are best read as estimates for comparing websites rather than exact figures. Google has no part in any of them.

What to bear in mind. All four measures describe the whole website rather than the single page that ranked, so a directory that appeared in several searches is counted once for each. We grouped the pages in the same way as our analysis of the kinds of page that rank in Bedford. To be fair to the businesses involved, we don’t publish the traffic estimate of any named business.

Key Terms Used in This Article

We have kept jargon to a minimum, although where a term couldn't be avoided, this is what it means.

Domain
A website's address, such as example.co.uk.
Domain age
The number of years since a website's address was first registered.
Backlink
A link to your website from another website.
Referring domains
The number of different websites that link to yours, however many links each one gives.
Authority score
A score from 0 to 100 given by an SEO tool to estimate a website's strength. Google doesn't use it.
Estimated traffic
An SEO tool's estimate of how many visits a month a website gets from Google searches.

Domain Age

The websites in the first five were mostly well established. 39 of the 85 pages belonged to websites whose addresses had been registered for more than 20 years, which is mainly because directories and national chains have been online for a long time.

How old the websites were

  • Up to 5 years
  • 6 to 10 years
  • 11 to 20 years
  • More than 20 years
  • Directories and booking sites 33 pages1428
  • National chain branch pages 13 pages76
  • Local business websites 33 pages59154

Years since the website's address was first registered. The four Bedford pages of firms covering several towns are left out of this and the charts below because there are too few to compare.

Local business websites were younger, with a typical age of 12 years and a middle half of 7 to 18 years. Five of them were three years old or less, including thetreesurgeonbedford.co.uk, which came first for tree surgeons.

Two of the newest websites belonged to tradespeople. Zenith Plastering's address was registered in May 2025 and the page ranked third for plasterers, while Dexters Build's address was registered in November 2025 and its Bedford page ranked fifth for roofers.

Referring Domains

Links from other websites are one of the signals Google has long used to judge which pages are most useful. Referring domains count how many different websites provide those links. This was where the gap between local businesses and directories was widest.

Referring domains for every page in the first five

  • Page in first place
  • Other pages in the first five
  • Middle half of each group
  • Directories and booking sitesMiddle half 9,700 to 43,500
  • National chain branch pagesMiddle half 4,300 to 9,200
  • Local business websitesMiddle half 316 to 1,600
101001,00010,000100,0001,000,000

Each step along the scale is ten times the one before, so that websites with a few hundred links and websites with hundreds of thousands fit on the same chart. Figures are for the whole website.

The typical directory had 30,400 websites linking to it and the typical national chain had 4,900, whereas the typical local business website had 393. The middle half of local websites had between 316 and 1,600, with the lowest at 63 and the highest at 6,500.

That is a difference of more than 75 times between the typical directory and the typical local website, yet local websites still took 33 of the 85 places in the first five.

We have various systems that understand how pages link to each other as a way to determine what pages are about and which might be most helpful in response to a query.

Google, A guide to Google Search ranking systems

Authority Score, a Third-Party Estimate

An authority score is a single number from 0 to 100 that an SEO tool calculates for each website, mainly from its links. It is useful for comparing websites quickly, although it is the tool's own estimate and Google doesn't use it.

Typical authority score by kind of page

  • Directories and booking sites64
  • National chain branch pages48
  • Local business websites10

Middle values on a scale of 0 to 100. The score is a third-party estimate and not a Google measure.

The typical directory scored 64, the typical national chain 48 and the typical local business website 10, the same figures we reported in our wider study. Scores also fell with position, from a typical 64 in first place to 20 in fifth, which is largely because directories took first place in 12 of the 17 searches.

Typical authority score at each position

  • First place64
  • Second place44
  • Third place26
  • Fourth place26
  • Fifth place20

Middle values for the 17 pages at each position. Directories took first place in 12 of the 17 searches.

When we compared every pair of pages within the same search, the website with the higher score ranked above the one with the lower score 110 times out of 165. In the other 55, the website with the lower score came out on top, which shows that the score is a guide rather than a rule.

110 of 165

times the website with the higher authority score ranked above the one with the lower score.

We compared every pair of pages in the same search. In the other 55, the weaker website came out on top.

Estimated Traffic

Estimated traffic is the SEO tool's guess at how many visits a month each website gets from Google searches in the UK. It covers the whole website rather than the page that ranked, so a national directory's estimate reflects visitors from every town and every service it covers.

Estimated visits a month from Google searches in the UK

  • Under 1,000
  • 1,000 to 9,999
  • 10,000 to 99,999
  • 100,000 or more
  • Directories and booking sites 33 pages11328
  • National chain branch pages 13 pages49
  • Local business websites 33 pages20103

Estimates for the whole website from an SEO tool, not counts of real visits.

The local business websites in the first five had small estimates. The typical one had around 300 visits a month, with a middle half of 71 to 1,700. None reached 100,000.

By contrast, 28 of the 33 directory pages and 9 of the 13 national chain pages belonged to websites with 100,000 or more estimated visits a month. We give these figures only as ranges and middle values, without publishing any named business's estimate.

Do Younger or Smaller Sites Still Win?

The short answer is yes, although not as often as the bigger websites. The table below shows the range of each measure in every search and whether the strongest website came first.

The range of each measure across the five websites in each search
IndustryDomain age (years)Referring domainsAuthority scoreWebsites with 100,000 or more estimated visitsStrongest website came first
Massage and spas2 to 29376 to 57,4008 to 742 of 5Yes
Restaurants2 to 26316 to 103,10011 to 952 of 5Yes
Hotels22 to 28852 to 434,60033 to 1004 of 5Yes
Pubs and bars18 to 30246 to 103,10021 to 953 of 5Yes
Dentists9 to 30433 to 5,70011 to 330 of 5Yes
Estate agents16 to 29419 to 43,50010 to 903 of 5Yes
Gyms12 to 22662 to 12,80034 to 692 of 5No
MOT and repairs8 to 31369 to 9,20023 to 683 of 5No
Takeaways15 to 241,200 to 103,10030 to 954 of 5No
Car dealers7 to 30314 to 30,40012 to 843 of 5Yes
Plumbers9 to 22360 to 40,3008 to 642 of 5Yes
Electricians11 to 23254 to 40,3008 to 642 of 5Yes
Accountants4 to 31358 to 70,0009 to 691 of 5No
Tree surgeons3 to 22227 to 40,3006 to 641 of 5No
Roofersunder 1 to 2246 to 40,3008 to 642 of 5Yes
Window cleaners4 to 22233 to 40,3008 to 642 of 5No
Plasterers1 to 2263 to 40,3006 to 642 of 5Yes

Strongest means the highest authority score among the five, including ties. Figures are for the whole website, so a directory that appears in several searches is counted each time.

The strongest website came first in 11 of the 17 searches. In the other six, a weaker website took first place. Four of those six were local businesses.

Local businesses in first place against the strongest website in the same search

  • Local business in first place
  • Strongest website in the first five
  • MOT and repairs: Motorvation Bedford against Kwik Fit in 2nd place2368
  • Accountants: Bedford Accountants against Yell in 5th place969
  • Tree surgeons: thetreesurgeonbedford.co.uk against Checkatrade in 3rd place964
  • Window cleaners: Bedford Window Cleaning against Checkatrade in 5th place1764

Authority scores out of 100, a third-party estimate that Google does not use.

Motorvation Bedford came first for MOTs above Kwik Fit, Bedford Accountants came first above Yell, Bedford Window Cleaning came first above Checkatrade and thetreesurgeonbedford.co.uk came first for tree surgeons with Checkatrade in third place. Each had an authority score of 23 or less against a rival scoring between 64 and 69.

Beyond first place, 23 of the 33 local business websites ranked above at least one website with a higher score. Website strength clearly helps, although it doesn't stop a smaller local website from ranking alongside and sometimes ahead of much bigger names.

4 of 4

local businesses in first place beat a far stronger website to it.

Each scored 23 or less against a rival scoring between 64 and 69.

What It Means for a Bedford Business

The checklist below turns this study into practical steps, with each one based on the websites that ranked for Bedford searches.

  1. Don't be put off by a big competitor, since four local businesses came first above websites with far higher scores.
  2. Don't judge your website by an outside tool's score, which Google doesn't use.
  3. Earn links from genuine local sources, such as suppliers, local organisations and the directories in your industry.
  4. Keep the same web address once you have it, since a long-established address is part of what the strongest websites share.
  5. Remember that a new website can still rank, as five local websites in the first five were three years old or less.
  6. Track the enquiries your website brings in rather than a traffic estimate.
  7. Concentrate on a clear page for your service in Bedford, a complete Google listing and genuine reviews alongside your links.
  8. Check every few months which websites rank above you and how they compare with yours.

A bigger website has an advantage, although four local businesses in our study came first against far stronger competition, which shows that a well-built local website still has a real chance of ranking.

If you would like to know how your website compares with the ones ranking above you, our SEO services for Bedford companies start with a full audit of your site and its competitors.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an authority score?
It is a score from 0 to 100 that an SEO tool gives a website to estimate its strength, based mainly on links. Google says it doesn't evaluate or endorse third-party SEO tools, which makes the score useful for comparing websites rather than something Google uses.
Does an older website rank better?
Directories and national chains were older, with typical ages of 22 and 20 years against 12 for local business websites. However, five local websites in the first five were three years old or less, including the one that came first for tree surgeons.
How many links does a local website need?
There is no set number. The local business websites in our study had between 63 and 6,500 referring domains, with a typical figure of 393, which is far fewer than the directories they were up against.
Can a small local business outrank Checkatrade?
Yes. Bedford Window Cleaning came first for window cleaners with an authority score of 17, above Checkatrade with 64, while thetreesurgeonbedford.co.uk came first for tree surgeons with a score of 9 and Checkatrade was third.
Should I worry about my website's traffic estimate?
Traffic estimates come from outside tools and are models rather than real counts. The typical local website in the first five had an estimated 300 visits a month from Google, so the enquiries your website brings in are a better measure.

Sources

  1. Our audit of Google results for 17 Bedford searches, recorded between 10 and 12 November 2026, with domain age from public registration records and the other website measures from a third-party SEO tool, checked on 10 and 11 November 2026.
  2. Google: Do you need an SEO?
  3. Google: A guide to Google Search ranking systems

Written by Andrew Odgers

Andrew is a director of Lillian Purge, the Bedford agency behind this study. Before moving into SEO, he worked as a contract auditor in the public sector and then as a circulation auditor in the media industry.

More about Andrew and the team